Skip to content

About & Best Posts
Glossary
Archive
Guest Article Submissions

Search for:

Celia Wagar's CritPoints

Critical Critique straight to the HP

Protected: Critique of Critique for Matthew Matosis on DkS2

March 20, 2015May 17, 2025Celia Wagar

This content is password-protected. To view it, please enter the password below.

Password:

Related

Critic Critique

Previous Article Control Schemes

Next Article Fighting Game Accessibility

Welcome to Celia Wagar’s Game Design Theory blog. Please check About and Best Posts if you’re new.
Twitter: @Evilagram
Support my Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/critpoints
Bluesky: @Celialicious.bsky.social
We have a really active Discord with civil in-depth discussion of games, plus a lot of silliness on the side, come join in: https://discord.gg/EfPY4r9

Categories

Card Games
Critic Critique
Depth
Design Ideas
Design Principles
Fighting Games
Game Commentary
GameDev
Games Ontology
Guest Posts
Immersion
Industry
Level Design
Mechanic Analysis
More Than Mashing
Other
Review Standards
Reviews/Overviews
Smash
SoulsBorne
Speedrunning
Story
Tutorials
Uncategorized

Recent Comments

	jh55 on Boosting Enemy Stats is not…
	jh55 on Parries are the Mindkille…
	Herb on Against Immersion: The Holodec…
	Celia Wagar on Bullet Bloom: An FPS Trag…
	Bloomberg on Bullet Bloom: An FPS Trag…

Recent Posts

Against Immersion: The Holodeck Must Burn December 14, 2025
Why Don’t We Know How to Design Games? September 18, 2025
Player Agency Doesn’t Make Sense September 16, 2025
Boosting Enemy Stats is not “Artificial Difficulty” September 15, 2025
Design Space: Dimensions of Game Design August 21, 2025
10 Years of Critpoints May 18, 2025
Building Counterplay for PvP Games May 6, 2025
I Don’t Really Like Deus Ex February 19, 2025
How to Code Fighting Game Motion Inputs February 5, 2025
VR is Focusing on the Wrong Things December 15, 2024
Scrubs & Johns: A Defense Against Bad Sportsmanship November 7, 2024
The Secret History of Zelda July 2, 2024
The Big Catch: Tacklebox Review June 27, 2024
Building Skill Tests @ Game Design Skills June 14, 2024
How to be a Good Fighting Game Community Member April 2, 2024
Parries are the Mindkiller March 30, 2024
Sometimes it’s No More than Mashing March 22, 2024
Roger Ebert was Right About Video Games and We Have Failed Him March 20, 2024
Game “Loops” are an Illusion March 18, 2024
It’s Not the Yellow Paint, It’s What the Paint Represents March 3, 2024
Cost Granularity in Card Games January 18, 2024
Celia’s Tips for Clear Writing August 5, 2023
Pseudoregalia Review July 30, 2023
How to Pick a Fighting Game Character June 3, 2023
What is Charmed Chains? (My New Card Game) May 30, 2023
Card Game Design as Systems Architecture May 26, 2023
Witcher 2 Review May 18, 2023
Mashing: Rote Memory vs System Mastery May 16, 2023
Tiers are for Queers May 14, 2023
How do you Set the MAXIMUM LIMIT? (For Health & such) May 14, 2023
How Magic’s Mana System Divides its Design Space May 10, 2023
The Hypothetical Worst Fighting Game May 9, 2023
What’s the Deal with Auto Combos? May 4, 2023
Tabletop Game Designers Know What’s Up April 25, 2023
SF6 is the Intro Game the Genre Needs April 24, 2023
Frame Data Patterns that ALL Game Designers Should Know February 20, 2023
Blocking is Cool Actually February 1, 2023
Sekiro is not a Souls-like April 20, 2022
The Traveling Soulsman March 12, 2022
Emergent Gameplay in Fighting Games March 6, 2022
How Fighting Games can Retain Players May 7, 2021
Visualizing the Skill Curve March 19, 2021
Dunkey Gets Dunked On February 21, 2021
FPS Boss Fights Don’t Have to Suck Ft. Durandal January 27, 2021
Getting Over It With Bennet Foddy Review December 13, 2020
Mirror’s Edge Review October 31, 2020
Isomorphism & Asymmetry September 24, 2020
Kill Your Sacred Cows September 19, 2020
Designing AGAINST Speedrunners September 18, 2020
Designing for Speedrunners September 16, 2020

Top Posts & Pages

Roger Ebert was Right About Video Games and We Have Failed Him
How to Perform Fighting Game Motions
Against Immersion: The Holodeck Must Burn
Good FPS Map Design
How to Pick a Fighting Game Character
5 Games, 5 Jumps
It's Not the Yellow Paint, It's What the Paint Represents
God Hand Dodging
Mirror's Edge Review
Archive

Blog at WordPress.com.

Subscribe Subscribed
- Celia Wagar's CritPoints
- Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.